The community of common sense in town’s future?

Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Annexation strategy must address municipal units in Montague area

Town of Montague

Montague Coun. Jim Bagnall was clearly unimpressed with options for new town boundaries presented during a council meeting Monday.

Two strategies were submitted by the Department of Municipal Affairs for annexation as the town seeks to grow and expand beyond its present restrictive boundaries.

Mr. Bagnall is correct, the strategies don’t make any sense since they don’t deal with the three largest municipal units closest to the town. The incorporated communities of Brudenell, Valleyfield and Lower Montague would seem the most logical areas for annexation and expansion. Why do they get a free pass?

Instead, planners suggested leapfrogging over these three units to gobble up far-flung areas.

One unwieldy strategy would see the town acquire about 2,800 acres in the unincorporated area of Victoria Cross while a second strategy would see the town annex 40,000 acres of unincorporated area from Heatherdale to Poole’s Corner and to Sturgeon and Panmure Island.

That region is basically the current boundaries of the Montague Fire District, and would double the population and double the town’s tax assessment rolls.

Anyone driving into Montague from Poole’s Corner is quickly aware of the heavy ribbon development along Highway 4, including dealerships, restaurants and others businesses — much of it in Brudenell.

There is no discernible boundary where Montague starts and Brudenell ends but there is a quite a difference in tax rates.

And that is really the crux of the problem. Brudenell, Lower Montague and Valleyfield all use services supplied by the town, such as the recreation complex, stores, library, fire coverage and various other services. But they pay less tax than residents inside Montague, which results in an unfair, two-tiered system.

Stagnant growth inside Montague makes it difficult to support what are, in effect, regional services. Businesses can’t find the necessary room inside the town to build or expand and are forced to locate outside the boundaries.

The town says the status quo is not working so changes must be made. For example, the library boasts 4,500 members while the town’s population is 1,900 residents, so more than half the users are from outside Montague.

Council was told the town must join forces with smaller, rural areas and perhaps create a ward system in order to survive. That makes sense but not without considering the three municipal units bordering on the town.

Montague of course is not alone dealing with this widespread problem. Many Island communities are in the same situation. Expensive new homes are built just outside municipal boundaries to avoid higher taxes. But those owners expect to benefit from everything the town or village has to offer, and basically enjoy a subsidy being paid by the residents inside that village or town.

As Montague Mayor Richard Collins correctly pointed out, it seems that government is flying a trial balloon here by trying to pass off annexation or amalgamation onto municipal units instead of making the tough but necessary decision itself.

The province has approved $15,000 for a Development of an Annexation Strategy, expected to be approved next month.

Mr. Bagnall favours no terms of reference but says to wait and see what the study would bring back. He is confident it will deal with the real problem and not push it to one side as the department has done.

Regional co-operation is the best way for towns like Montague to prosper. All areas covered by the Montague fire department — including Brudenell, Lower Montague and Valleyfield — should be in the new municipal unit. You can call it Montague or Three Rivers or just common sense.

Organizations: Department of Municipal Affairs, Three Rivers

Geographic location: Montague, Valleyfield, Panmure Island Many Island

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Peggy Coffin
    January 31, 2014 - 07:32

    Rural Observer lays bare the facts that the article fails to mention. There is no such thing as a free ride. We all depend on each other. Cooperation, not annexation or amalgamation, is what is needed. There are many empty areas in Montague, covered in tulips or Christmas decorations, in prime locations, why the push for more land?

  • ruralobserver
    January 29, 2014 - 15:14

    This editorial overlooks the fact that the outlying communities, such as Brudenell, pay a significant amount of Fire Dues to Montague annually, the Library is within the Wellness Centre which was built with funding from the Province, Rotary, Cavendish Farms and theTown of Montague. The Community of Brudenell contributes approx. one sixth of it's annual budget to the Wellness Centre so we are getting no free ride. Indeed many of the members of the Fire Dept. live outside of the Montague boundaries. It is also interesting to note that the Montague CAO does not live in Montague !

    • Also Add
      January 29, 2014 - 18:12

      Also add that these services they are talking about like stores - medical centre -are put there by the business owners who if you check mostly live outside Montague . The town is not paying to have them - they are receiving taxes from them . A little different than being put forward in this article . As far as expansion goes , fill up some of the empty buildings on main street wit other than goverment supported offices and two year grant businesses , otherwise called fly by night . Ask the question why these buildings are empty ???????

  • Squirrel
    January 29, 2014 - 10:06

    The above article says it on the nose. How many studies have we had on Regional Gov't, all of which recommend Regional Gov't, the last one was thew Thompson Report. No ACTION was taken . This situation is happening all over the Island - just look at the Morell, for example. Common sense says get it done NOW .