Criticizing New Brunswick could be costly

Alan Holman
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Robert Ghiz and his fellow premiers gathered in Charlottetown this week for their annual summer beanfest.

These meetings began a few decades ago are based on the simple premise that it is good for people who have to deal with one another on matters of state then they should get to know each other better; as real people, over a couple of drinks, a barbecue and perhaps a round or two of golf. It started out with just the ten leaders, and their families, gathering for a casual summer get together. All very informal.

Well those days are long gone. The simple premiers’ conflab is now, (a drum roll, please) The Council of Confederation. Instead of just the ten provincial leaders, there were 160 delegates in attendance. And, with a pack of the always ‘politically-correct' press ever present (think Evan Solomon), the premiers couldn't be seen enjoying themselves at the taxpayers expense. So they auctioned themselves off to the corporations and unions, who it seems, were willing to pony up some $500,000 to be able to rub elbows with the provincial nabobs.

Premier Ghiz doesn’t think there is any conflict of interest in having their suppers and entertainment paid for. In his opinion “it’s about supporting democracy.”

Unions and corporations donating money to help political parties and candidates to run election campaigns might be seen as supporting the democratic process. But, this summer gathering has nothing to do with democracy, possibly something to do with governance. One shouldn’t confuse the two.

Nonetheless, the meetings began amid a chorus of gratuitous advice, much of it having to do with the evils and shortcomings of the present federal government, and the devil incarnate who leads it.

One voice in that chorus, singing slightly off tune, given the presumably collegial nature of the gathering, was our own provincial journal, which covers the Island like the dew, don’tcha know.  A week ago, The Guardian shed a few of its journalistic dew drops on southeastern New Brunswick, particularly noting that the highway running just east of the rotary at Port Elgin wasn’t up to scratch. The three to five kilometres highlighted in the article were seen to be bumpy, with potholes and many, many patches.

On Monday, in an editorial The Guardian decided that the Council of the Federation “offers Premier Robert Ghiz a perfect chance to discuss the matter with N.B. Premier David Alward.”

One can only hope that Mr. Ghiz ignored this advice, but, if he chose to raise the matter then one should pray that Premier Alward came to the Island by air, and didn’t drive on any of our roads.

If he drove, then he might have observed that a stretch of the Trans Canada just east of Tryon is just as bumpy and no less patched than the road near Port Elgin.

Should Mr. Alward have driven east of Charlottetown then he would have noted that the Trans Canada near Mont Mellick is somewhat less than smooth, again there are patches on the patches.

If Premier Alward drove on any of our secondary roads, say the Seven Mile Road that runs from Cardigan to Bridgetown, he would have found a stretch of that road that makes the Port Elgin highway seem positively pristine.

In its story a week ago The Guardian quoted Scott Annear, chair of the P.E.I. Trucking Sector Council as saying the state of NB Highway 16 has meant P.E.I. drivers and trucking companies have incurred regular costs for repairs.

Premier Alward may have legitimately asked if Mr. Annear was sure it was only the New Brunswick road that caused the problem. And the premier might have said that while Highway 16 may be important to P.E.I., it actually serves very few New Brunswick citizens. He might have added that even though it is a section of the Trans Canada Highway, Highway 16 is just one of the many secondary roads in the province that his taxpayers pay to maintain.

Premier Alward may have also asked Mr. Annear if he appreciated the more than 520 kilometers of four-lane Trans Canada Highway that runs from the Quebec border to Nova Scotia. It is one of the least congested highways in the country and a real boon to the trucking industry.

If he wanted to be really nasty, then Premier Alward might have suggested, that since Islanders are the chief beneficiaries of Highway 16 then maybe they should contribute to its maintenance by paying a toll.

Alan Holman is a freelance journalist living in Charlottetown. He can be reached at:

Organizations: Council of Confederation, Trans Canada Highway, P.E.I. Trucking Sector Council

Geographic location: New Brunswick, Charlottetown, Port Elgin Iceland Canada Tryon Mont Mellick Cardigan Bridgetown Quebec Nova Scotia

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Al
    September 02, 2014 - 19:17

    Maybe islanders should pay a toll on nb good highways all the way to que. highways are divided and 110 km speed limit.How many 110km highways on pei??

  • Quiet Observer
    September 02, 2014 - 11:04

    What Mr. Holman chooses to ignore is that this is the Trans Canada Highway, linking all the provinces of Canada. Something guaranteed in joining Canada. the rough sections of PEI TCH exist, but Mr. Alward also would have noted that they do not hold a candle in roughness to these NB sections, are in fact, are being repaired here on PEI. Being a frequent traveler on route 16, I think NB should be embarrassed that it repaired Route 955 (shabbily mind you) before it did route 16, when 955 might at best see 1/100th of the vehicle traffic. I tend to think the NB has grown a distaste for PEIslanders, even though Moncton, and the provincial HST coffers, benefit greatly from PEI shoppers and the NB government benefits greatly on HST and gas tax from everyone who fills up in NB either on the way to or from PEI because gas is cheaper there. Shame, Mr. Alward, shame. And shame Mr. Holman for such a great distortion.

  • Aongasha
    August 30, 2014 - 18:41

    Nice job on the skewering Allan, I might hire you for my next shish kabob BBQ. Speaking of the always politiclly correct Evan Soloman, did you notice the spit he's trying to peddle today? The Premiers supposely on a collision course with the Feds? Yeah right! Not in our lifetime or our children's. These people do nothing but beg from the Feds, try to start fights with them for headline purposes and pose for photo-ops. They are all scared spitless of Harper - he's much too smart for all of them. Funniest thing about Soloman and CBC was the Friday night P&P power panel. His gang even laughingly admitted they were reading stories about the meeting and then suddenly realized they were old stories from years gone by and nothing had changed. And folks wonder why the PM ignores the premiers and the people ignore CBC. Both are redundant!