Putting yourself at risk is wrong choice

Letters to the Editor (The Guardian)
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Personal autonomy should not come ahead of personal safety and risk to others

Tour de France cyclist Alessandro De Marchi’s helmet is visible as he cools off during the 14th stage of the race recently.

Guest Opinion: There have been several recent letters to The Guardian protesting mandatory helmet laws. As a career emergency physician and a longtime coroner, I have had the unfortunate experience of seeing the tragic consequences of poor decision making over and over again.

Later in my career, while working in rehabilitation and long-term care, I had to care for patients who had sustained life-altering injuries because they didn’t wear a helmet, a seat belt or a personal floatation device.

For some of them, their decision not to maximize their own protection while engaged in a potentially dangerous activity was influenced by their objection to being told what to do, the “you’re not my mother” or “who made you the boss of me?” argument.

For others, they were impaired by alcohol or other drugs which clouded their judgment. For otherwise law-abiding individuals who decided at the last minute to take a chance, it was as much a matter of bad luck as bad judgment.

For all, their injuries were a lot more serious than they would have been had they been wearing protective equipment. Unfortunately, the consequences of their actions are borne by more than just the injured individual. They are shared by their loved ones, their friends and society as a whole. We all end up paying for their mistakes.

I can understand the strong need for personal autonomy. Alas, the conscious decision to put oneself and others at risk is the wrong choice. If an adult chooses to drink, or drug and drive, not wear a seat belt, enter a construction site without wearing a safety helmet or safety boots, go out on the water without wearing a PFD, or ride a bicycle or motorcycle without using legally required safety equipment, they should either be required to sign a lifestyle waiver absolving society of the responsibility of paying for their care should they become injured as a direct consequence of their action, or have their claims for coverage of the cost of such care rejected. Sometimes, the rights of society do take precedence over those of the individual.

Desmond Colohan, MD, coroner, lives in Charlottetown.

Geographic location: Charlottetown

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Lita Arnold
    July 24, 2014 - 13:14

    Thank you Dr Colohan for your very explicit letter to the Guardian July 23 regarding helmet laws. That article should be read by the riders who don't have the brain to realize this is a safety measure in case they fall off their bike. Plus saving the province enormous amount of money for your care when you have brain injury as well as sparing your family from unbelievable grief. Lita Arnold Malpeque

  • Quiet Observer
    July 24, 2014 - 07:13

    What is wrong with people making their own decisions and being responsible for their own consequences? Are we a bunch of idiots that need government to tell us what to do and what not to do? We are very well heading down to the path predicted by George Orwell (just not quite as quickly).

  • individual
    July 24, 2014 - 06:46

    I am deeply concerned about the last sentence: "Sometimes, the rights of society do take precedence over those of the individual." Society (or groups) do not have rights. Individual rights have precedence over everything else. It is not the role of government to tell individuals how to live their lives. It is up to the individual to decide if they want to wear safety boots, a helmet, a seat belt or a personal floatation device. Not government. Not ever.

  • Hawkins
    July 23, 2014 - 20:37

    I agree 100 % with this opinion. Individual rights are one thing, but common sense approaches to injury prevention are an essential part of a society with socialized medicine.

  • brian jeffery
    July 23, 2014 - 17:30

    One could also add to the list people who eat junk, smoke, drink, and never exercise. More people die from what they put on the dinner plate than riding without a helmet!