Charlottetown activist fears uprooting of health care

Jim Day
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Mary Boyd keeping eye on B.C. legal action seeking to ban private health care

Mary Boyd

Mary Boyd is keeping a keen eye on a constitutional challenge of British Columbia’s ban on private health care.

She fears if the challenge, launched by former Canadian Medical Association president Dr. Brian Day, is successful, the ramifications will be felt across Canada, including P.E.I.

“As soon as you start undermining health care like that and you get a chain reaction, you’re going to get a two-tier system where there will be extra billing of patients and double dipping,’’ says Boyd, chairwoman of the P.E.I. Health Coalition.

“We have a Canada Health Act that is supposed to protect us from that.’’

A lawsuit against the B.C. government by Day, a Vancouver orthopedic surgeon and co-owner of the Cambie Surgery Centre, was set to go to trial earlier this month.

But lawyers on both sides agreed last week to seek an adjournment so some issues can be settled out of court to improve the speed of the eventual trial.

The B.C. government has said the taxpayer-funded public health-care system is based on the idea that access to medical care is based on need, not the ability to pay.

Boyd would like to see the challenge die before reaching the Supreme Court of British Columbia.

She dismisses Day’s argument that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms gives people the right to seek faster health care through private facilities if they are unhappy with the public system.

“It has been proven over and over again that a two-tier system actually extends the waiting times ... what happens though is people can jump the queue,’’ says Boyd.

“The poorest in Canada should be able to walk into a doctor’s office or a medical facility and get equal treatment to the richest person in Canada.’’

Boyd says if Day wins this case it will set a precedent that approves unlawful charging of patients for insured health care and give a green light to similar private clinics across the country.

She says Canadians must send a clear message to the B.C. government and other provincial governments that Canada’s public health-care system must be defended and patients need to be protected from for-profit clinics and from unlawful billing.

“The people have to be vocal enough to see that it doesn’t happen,’’ says

Boyd.

“And the polls are always with the people. Massively, Canadians support our public health-care system.’’

Organizations: Canadian Medical Association, P.E.I. Health Coalition, Cambie Surgery Centre Supreme Court Charter

Geographic location: B.C., Canada, Charlottetown British Columbia Vancouver

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Dave
    September 29, 2014 - 23:35

    “It has been proven over and over again that a two-tier system actually extends the waiting times ... what happens though is people can jump the queue,’’ says Boyd. --------- Define "proven"? We don't have private health in Canada, so it is nothing more than speculation, far from proof. I say she simply made that tidbit up.

  • Dave
    September 29, 2014 - 23:24

    She dismisses Day’s argument that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms gives people the right to seek faster health care through private facilities if they are unhappy with the public system. “It has been proven over and over again that a two-tier system actually extends the waiting times ... what happens though is people can jump the queue,’’ says Boyd. ---------The charter protects individual rights not group rights. Her argument falls apart really fast. A doctor shortage at this period in history could have no bearing on a charter challenge , when that decision will have a lasting impact.

  • sasha
    September 29, 2014 - 10:55

    We are on a family-doctor-waiting-list for years now. At this time it is impossible for us to get proper health care here. Due to lack on any kind of centralized record keeping, walk-in clinic doctors rely on us knowing what medication were we prescribed and when. Regular full physical checkup at least once every 5 years is way beyond our reach. I am sure we could save enough to be able to pay once every 5 years to someone to have that checkup done and to have the place where walk-in clinic "incident reports" could be sent and records kept. I would welcome the option to be able to pay for some basic health care services as right now we cannot access them at all.