Prince Edward Island joining Ontario-led advisory committee to draft pension plan

Teresa Wright
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

P.E.I. Premier Robert Ghiz was in Toronto Wednesday where he announced he is working with Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne and Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger to develop a provincial pension plan

Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne met with P.E.I. Premier Robert Ghiz Wednesday about improving the Canadian Pension Plan.

Prince Edward Island is teaming up with Ontario and Manitoba to develop a provincial pension plan that would supplement retirement income, but business groups are raising concern over this initiative, calling it a ‘payroll tax.’

P.E.I. Premier Robert Ghiz was in Toronto Wednesday where he announced he is working with Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne and Manitoba Premier Greg Selinger to develop a provincial pension plan that would act as a supplement to the current Canadian Pension Plan (CPP).

“We know that we’ve got an aging population, that retirement security is important and that when it comes to private sector pension plans, we have among the lowest rates in the country for participation in them,” Ghiz said in a telephone interview from Toronto.

“We want to look at long-range plans to help ensure that there’s going to be adequate retirement plans for our seniors.”

The P.E.I. government has been front and centre in a national dialogue on the need for pension enhancements for the last several months.

Finance Minister Wes Sheridan pitched the notion of boosting the CPP by raising premiums and did gain consensus among the country’s finance ministers on the idea, but federal Finance Minister Jim Flaherty rejected it in December.

Ontario has since decided to move ahead with its own pension improvements, and now P.E.I. and Manitoba are also on board.

But the Canadian Federation of Independent Business says small business owners have expressed firm opposition to any plan that would see employers having to pay into a mandatory pension plan.

“Essentially it acts as a payroll tax,” said P.E.I. CFIB spokeswoman Erin McGrath-Gaudet.

“Anytime you’re making it more expensive to employ people, that has impacts on small business, that has impacts on the workforce, that has impacts on the economy as a whole.”

A mandatory provincial pension plan would not only be a financial strain for employers, but also for workers, who could pay as much as $1,100 more a year in premiums, she said.

A public opinion poll conducted for the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) by Angus Reid Global in 2013, found 65 per cent of working Canadians said they could not afford to save any more than they were already saving for retirement.

McGrath-Gaudet added that P.E.I. is already one of the highest-taxed jurisdictions in the country.

“Even things like the (provincial) fees and permits and licences in the last few years have gone up and now we’re going to start taking more money off of people’s paychecks?” McGrath-Gaudet said.

“We’re already seeing a lot of out-migration specifically because people are trying to make ends meet in this province, there’s a lot of challenges here… this is certainly not going to make it any easier.”

But Ghiz says when seniors don’t have enough money for retirement, it has negative impacts on the health system and social programs.

“Yes, it’s going to be a bit difficult… but this is essentially finding a way to enhance retirement incomes. And realistically right now retirement incomes are not keeping up with what retirees need, so this is a way to work on a long-term solution.”

P.E.I. and Manitoba will join Ontario’s Technical Advisory Group on Retirement Security. They will explore the most effective alternatives to a CPP enhancement.

Ghiz added nothing would change immediately. Any possible implementation would not likely happen until 2017.


Organizations: Registered Pooled Pension Plans, Canadian Press

Geographic location: Prince Edward Island, Ontario, Manitoba Ottawa

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Quiet Observer
    March 06, 2014 - 12:20

    As much as I dislike Ghiz and his politics, I think this is a good idea. And please note, I am a small independent business owner. Yes, this will cost me a little, but I am prepared to work around that if it will help the crisis retiring people are now facing. Noone can live on CPP and OAS. Noone. And we have Flaherty and his cronies in Ottawa, all guaranteed huge pensions, deciding that our retirees don't deserve to be able to live. As far as I am concerned go for it. A two or three percent increase in my payrol taxes is not going to make or break my business, but it may just help our retirees.

    • JP
      March 06, 2014 - 14:34

      Except that this won't help those who are retired or near retirement. You would have to pay in for a significant amount of time in order to see benefits. When there was talk of doubling CPP you were going to have to pay in for 40 years to actually see double benefits. If you are in favour of something like this and want to help your employees, I have to ask if you have a retirement plan for them like a Group RRSP?

  • John G
    March 06, 2014 - 11:36

    It's a great idea. For all those people who retire with next to no pension and the rest of us that would like more.

    March 06, 2014 - 07:33

    If Ghiz and Wes are for it then it is extremely bad for the people of PEI. Every time these two run out of money to award to cronies they raise taxes, borrow more money like 200 million yesterday financed over 40 years, They will take you money for a pension plan now because they will not be around when it is time to pay out as the province will be so far it debt it cannot pay for essentials let alone more pension plans. Another money grab by Wes and Ghiz.

  • me
    March 05, 2014 - 19:09

    THIS SHOULD BE GOOD. Two bankrupt provinces coming up with a retirement plan. Its almost laughable if it wasn't such a bad situation. Just another tax for islanders.

  • Unbelievable
    March 05, 2014 - 17:38

    It seems like everything people don't want Ghiz goes ahead with. This is ridiculous we are taxed through the teeth here. Stop making living SO DIFFICULT. PLEASE!!!!

  • My opinion
    March 05, 2014 - 16:05

    Wynne & Ghiz are two of the worst premiers in Canada & both Ontario & PEI are slowly being ruined by their leaderships. These two are not there for the people. They are for THEMSELVES.

    • Real Canadian
      March 05, 2014 - 18:59

      They both had great a great teacher. Ole Dalton