• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (18)
  •  

Conservatives: Tie personal tax exemption to CPI

Opposition finance critic James Aylward Guardian photo

Opposition finance critic James Aylward

Published on March 1, 2013
Published on February 28, 2013
Teresa Wright  RSS Feed

James Aylward says Prince Edward Island has lowest personal tax exemption in Canada

Topics :
Prince Edward Island , Canada

The Prince Edward Island government should index the basic personal tax exemption to the consumer price index, says Opposition finance critic James Aylward.

Islanders are only allowed to keep $7,708 of their income before they start paying taxes. He said this is the lowest basic personal exemption in the country.

Aylward said Thursday this amount has not changed since the Ghiz government took power in 2007.

“Meanwhile, they continue to increase the cost of fees, services, property taxes and now with the HST is coming in as well it just seems that they’re very satisfied, very content to continue to take money out of the pockets of Islanders.”

P.E.I. is also one of just three provinces that still do not index their tax brackets to reflect inflation, as well as increases in federal EI and CPP payroll contributions. This means increases in income necessary to keep in step with inflation every year bump more income into higher and higher tax brackets, leading to Islanders paying more taxes.

Aylward said indexing the personal exemption to CPI would help ease Islanders’ taxation burdens as they prepare to pay a new tax when the HST is implemented this spring.

“It would put a few hundred dollars back in every Islanders’ pocket and, in turn, Islanders are going to spend that money and it would help the economy,” Aylward said.

He further pointed out government has tied future provincial fee increases and property tax increases to CPI. He wonders why the personal tax exemption cannot be treated in the same manner.

Finance Minister Wes Sheridan was out of the province Thursday. But previously he has told The Guardian changes to the personal taxation formula would not happen until after the budget is balanced, which could be as late as 2016.

 

twright@theguardian.pe.ca

Comments

  • Bill Kays
    Bill Kays
    - March 1, 2013 at 18:29:39

    The puppets are both dancing to the same puppeteer. Of course it should be tied to the index. Balancing the budget on the backs of the poor is a dangerous thing to do. When the backs of the poor finally break altogether what do you think is going to happen? There will be anarchy in the streets and the big gov knows it. All it will take is one miscalculation on big gov's part to throw our economy out the window. Big gov is being run by the big banks, the bond makers, the credit brokers, the scabs of the planet. Government knows exactly how much or how little to squeeze out of us without killing us. They seem to enjoy the suffering of the poor people because they would sooner drag $1. a penny at a time from a suffering poor person, rather than taking it from a rich or well off person who wouldn't even notice it gone. This is what is wrong with the world and it is called greed. In a fair world the ones that have take care of the ones that do not have BECAUSE IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO. Does anyone teach right from wrong anymore or is "what can I get away with today?" the only thing being taught.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Agree with Mr. Kays
      - March 2, 2013 at 02:41:46

      I agree with you Mr. Kays, this is exactly what is happening. One example of the provincial liberals miscalculation was the gamble with the pensions when playing with the "scabs of the planet" as you so appropriately named them. But you know what they say about 'birds of a feather, they flock together'. The stupidity of such a gamble resulted in their loss of the entire pension savings. But, a gamble the governement has thrown back on the taxpayers. Introducing the worst tax in history, HST. Destructive to every province where it was implemented. You need money to stimulate the economy. If the people do not have any money to spend then the economy will stall and fail. To those businesses who think they are going to get extra dollars from this, you are sorrily mistaken. No one willl have any extra money to even go out to restaurants, you will loose more business than gain with the HST. To introduce this to islanders who are over taxed, have one of the lowest standards of living, an almost destroyed middle class (what is left of it) with most islanders just barely making ends meet with many unable to do this. HST will cause further moves off the island for those who can afford to get out, (many have left), and that means more taxing of the few poor people who are left. The future looks gloomy. This is how anarchy resulted in other places, there is only so much suffering people can endure while the greedy affluent rich and their priviledged greedy friends live like Kings, multi-millionaires from the backs of the hard working and poor. There is a great deal of suffering among islanders at present. But, an ignorant greedy government and opposition cons don't even notice as they are too busy with feeding at the trough, paying off, and cover-ups...who has time to even look at the way their behavior is and has been harming islanders, example- their pay raise....they have lost their minds along with a total grip on the way islanders have had to resort to food banks due to hunger. And they give themselves a raise with all the extra perks and trips to nomads lands. Sick, sad, pathetic, inhuman group of disgraceful, shameful representatives of corruption.

  • Username
    NDP government needed asap
    - March 1, 2013 at 17:42:12

    I have never seen such a disgraceful group of corrupt politicians that represent 2 parties at the same time, Just years of corruption and wrongdoing, greed, abuses of power, from both parties. I could never vote liberal or tory ever again. I have never seen such a blatent group of greedy, corrupt idiots who couldn't manage to do a good thing for islanders even if they were forced to- as it would be pocketed somehow into their greedy pockets. Liberals have governed as if most islanders do not exist except for them and their greedy connected friends; the tories went down when the backroom overthrew their leader and in doing so overthrew the entire party- rather fitting end for the tories. NDP is our only hope and so far the NDP leader has been great. He just needs some good reps and form the next government.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    NDP government needed asap
    - March 1, 2013 at 17:40:49

    I have never seen such a disgraceful group of corrupt politicians that represent 2 parties at the same time, Just years of corruption and wrongdoing, greed, abuses of power, from both parties. I could never vote liberal or tory ever again. I have never seen such a blatent group of greedy, corrupt idiots who couldn't manage to do a good thing for islanders even if they were forced to- as it would be pocketed somehow into their greedy pockets. Liberals have governed as if most islanders do not exist except for them and their greedy connected friends; the tories went down when the backroom overthrew their leader and in doing so overthrew the entire party- rather fitting end for the tories. NDP is our only hope and so far the NDP leader has been great. He just needs some good reps and form the next government.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    revelation
    - March 1, 2013 at 17:14:57

    Mr. Alyward hopefully knows that it was The Joan of Arc PC(Pat Mella) who initiated this ripoff and this other crew of duds continued it. Agree with the comment above-no difference between the LIEBRALS and PRIVILEGED CONS(PCS).

    Submit a comment

  • Bill Kays
    Bill Kays
    - March 1, 2013 at 16:25:36

    The puppets are both dancing to the same puppeteer. Of course it should be tied to the index. Balancing the budget on the backs of the poor is a dangerous thing to do. When the backs of the poor finally break altogether what do you think is going to happen? There will be anarchy in the streets and the big gov knows it. All it will take is one miscalculation on big gov's part to throw our economy out the window. Big gov is being run by the big banks, the bond makers, the credit brokers, the scabs of the planet. Government knows exactly how much or how little to squeeze out of us without killing us. They seem to enjoy the suffering of the poor people because they would sooner drag $1. a penny at a time from a suffering poor person, rather than taking it from a rich or well off person who wouldn't even notice it gone. This is what is wrong with the world and it is called greed. In a fair world the ones that have take care of the ones that do not have BECAUSE IT IS THE RIGHT THING TO DO. Does anyone teach right from wrong anymore or is "what can I get away with today?" the only thing being taught.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    A Joke
    - March 1, 2013 at 14:36:25

    Both the liberals and tories are corrupt, liars, and theives. Just one group of cons babbling to another group of cons . The subject matter is irrelevant as neither group listens to Islanders, or represents any form of democracy as they both have shown their greedy, self serving needs takes priority over anyone and all else. Just news to distract islanders from the mess we are in due to years of corruption from both parties.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Back to the backroom
    - March 1, 2013 at 14:17:23

    and what does Jimmy's party represent? A group of backstabbers who overthrew their own leader to allow the continuation of cover ups and needed to overthrow a female leader who refused to be bullied by a bunch of backstabbing non-elected hoodlums; who refused to have transparency, some honesty, and openness. This guy is expected to be taken seriously? Sorry, Jim, the backroom boys sunk the party, you and this new progressive corrupted is nothing but another costly joke to taxpayers. Back to the backroom bud!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Quiet Observer
    - March 1, 2013 at 12:23:09

    I can't believe anyone would give Aylward ctredit for this issue - Olive raised this issue a few years ago.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Joe Blow
    - March 1, 2013 at 11:57:48

    Well Wes Sheridan has no intentions in balancing the budget and all his attempts to do so have failed....so Sheridan needs to resign or try something new. This is a chance for the Liberals to do their job and look after Islanders. More money in the pockets of Islanders means more money injected into the economy. Only stupid politicians think that its best to make people poor to pay for government mistakes. That being said....I have no intentions in listening to any Tory. They have done their share of crooked dealings. NDP all the way for this chap!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Old Lady
    - March 1, 2013 at 08:49:36

    I read the article and I agree with Aylward. Income tax takes a fairly good chunk out of household spending. If fees are tied to the CPI, then the exemption should also be. As far as Sheridan's statement goes, well, that budget might be balanced if it weren't for reckless spending on frivolous things. That statement is a further insult to Islanders, especially those of us on old age pension and a meagre personal pension. Raising a family of good citizens cost me a lot so I don't have savings. Tax the people for food, clothing, transportation, heat, electricity, shelter, services of professionals, etc. Must be great to be rich enough not to worry about it! I know I am losing sleep wondering how I will survive.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Bertie
      - March 1, 2013 at 12:28:08

      Sure Aylward wil say many thing that we can " agree" with. But that is not what is most important here. The Tories are in on every scam with the LIbs- PNP, Plan B, HST. Aylward may throw out ideas but he speaks for a Tory back room as every bit as self serving as the Ghiz one. There is no difierence between Liberal and Conservative. We can have change but we need to vote NDP to get it.

  • Username
    Peiguy
    - March 1, 2013 at 08:35:22

    "Out of the mouths of Babes" keep having good ideas like this one James and You may become an actual voice of the people. Good to see a suggestion offered. Mr. Premier this is one idea he would not mind if you take and claim as already in the works. after all it would be a tangible benefit to Islanders who might have a little bit more disposable income, they then spend it supporting the economy. and you get more hst son it doesn't end up as a true loss rather a temporary distribution of wealth that benefits more Islanders in need.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Trust a Tory
    - March 1, 2013 at 08:23:49

    ..and come look at some prime swamp land I have for sale.... no thanks no way!!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    At Last . . .maybe.
    - March 1, 2013 at 08:06:35

    At last this issue gets into the light of day! Now, how long will it stay there and will anything be done? This is one of those "boring" things that fatually matters to a lot of Islanders, but too few care to understand what's happening. Yeah, there's not much drama here and as the kids say, it doesn't "POP". But it matters. Past governments have been able to negotiate pay increases with one hand and then silently claw back the increase by manipulating the basic personal exemption level. And then we stupidly scratch our heads and wonder why we feel we're sliding backwards! And let's be clear, the unions being silent on this makes them complicit with this scam. Both groups are basically shilling people by creating the illusion of monetary gain. A curse on both your houses. So, let's see if Alyward and this wonky PC party is for real, or just prone to political posturing. Islanders that understand this issue will be watching . . . and we won't forget.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    backroom backstabbers are back
    - March 1, 2013 at 03:44:47

    Who is this group? and they represent islanders? more like their own selfish, self serving needs. Go row your boats quickly out to sea boys! don't forget to take your knives with you. Another embarassment for this Island.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Shadows from the backroom
    - March 1, 2013 at 03:33:40

    Was this Aylward speaking or did I see some shadows in the background? oh, guess he is not in the backroom at present. so, the progressively corrupt party of 130 backstabbing members want to talk....Talk about your undemocratic stances, oppressive and bullying natures, and talk about when you will do a thorough, open and transparent investigation on pnps that the you are all involved in. Until then, don't listen to oppressive, women haters, violators of people's rights, and those that threaten and backstab to get their own way. Talk to the hand. Meantime, I might suggest your backroom read "How to do polling for dummies"

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    don
    - March 1, 2013 at 02:32:05

    James Aylward. that is to help pay your wages and the close friends of the government on both sides.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Expert bloggers

Ride for Heart
Blogger
Heart and Stroke Foundation
Putting those unused gears into action
[Sponsored]

More bloggers here

The Guardian Twitter

Advertising