• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (16)
  •  

Islander's EI protest lands in Parliament

Marlene Giersdorf has risen to national attention after new EI rules ended her claim and pushed her towards provincial welfare. Guardian photo

Marlene Giersdorf has risen to national attention after new EI rules ended her claim and pushed her towards provincial welfare.

Published on January 29, 2013
Published on January 29, 2013
Steve Sharratt  RSS Feed
Topics :
Employment Insurance , Service Canada , Conservatives , MONTAGUE , Charlottetown , Ottawa

MONTAGUE — The federal government needs to “come to its senses” and reverse the changes to Employment Insurance that are hurting people like a P.E.I. single mother recently cut off from her benefits, Cardigan MP Lawrence MacAulay said Monday.

“Marlene Giersdorf is a single mother from my riding who recently got kicked off EI by this Conservative government,” said MacAulay, who hammered the federal government during question period in Ottawa Monday.

“She was told that since she could not drive over 60 kilometres (to Charlottetown) to look for possible work, she would have to go on welfare. The minister said she couldn’t contact Marlene, when in fact she has been protesting right outside the Service Canada office in Montague.”

The 30-year-old woman has risen to national attention after new EI rules ended her claim and pushed her towards provincial welfare. She couldn’t take a job in Charlottetown because she doesn’t own a car and there is no public transit. Many other EI claimants, who have not gone public, are also being cut off benefits.

While Giersdorf was protesting outside the Service Canada building here last week, the parliamentary secretary for Human Resources Minister Diane Finley was 20 minutes away in Belfast participating in a community financing announcement with National Revenue Minister Gail Shea. There was no meeting between the politicians and the protester.

“It’s time to take away all the mythology . . . I can’t speak to this directly, but I encourage (Giersdorf) to take advantage of the excellent personnel at Service Canada and go through the details of her case,’’ said Dr. Kellie Leitch. “If there is no job in her local area for her set (of) skills, then employment insurance will continue to be available.”

Giersdorf has been advised her appeal to regain her claim is being reviewed and a verdict will be coming around Valentine’s Day. She was in personal appointments Monday.

“Our service officers have reached out to her on more than one occasion,’’ said Leitch. “Only she can choose to come in the office and take advantage of our services. If she doesn’t want to take our offer of help to find a job or the tools to be employed, that is her choice.”

Leitch said the single mother of a nine-year-old attending a local school is expected to do a reasonable job search and network to find employment. Giersdorf, who doesn’t have a phone and works on a seasonal basis, has been both praised and reviled in the media comments attached to any Internet story.

“We are not skating around the issue,” the Simcoe/Grey MP said in an interview with The Guardian. “We will make benefits available as long as she meets the criteria.”

Leitch said her Ontario riding is filled with seasonal workers and “they are delighted” with EI changes, she said, because it allows them to get jobs if they wish and they don’t have to drive three hours to Toronto.

MacAulay says vulnerable Canadians, like Giersdorf, are being asked to pay the price for Conservative incompetence and front-line cuts.

“These changes to EI are absolutely shameful. There are so many people who work in rural areas and simply cannot afford to buy a car or move their families to a larger town or city. These people, and these areas of the country, are being unfairly targeted and hurt by this government and I truly hope the Conservatives come to their senses and reverse these changes before more families are devastated.”

Comments

  • Username
    fed up
    - January 30, 2013 at 21:07:03

    This story is really getting old wow what about other women and men who cant get jobs and there ei has run out are they all going to be standing in a line up at macdonalds getting free lunch and an offer to get a free car when is it going to end . what about cancer patients or any other sick person who had to leave there jobs due to sickness and have to apply else where to get help why dont we as islanders kick in and help the people who really need it with a sick spouse and could use the support This lady going on about cant take a job in Charlottetown because her son goes to school in Montaque wow im sure her sons dad would be more then willing to accomadate her expecially when her son lives with his dad . and what about her bfriend who has a car and a truck he cant take her to work .geee ill drive from charlottetown and go pick her up if it means putting food on her table for her son as she says .also she quit her job because she was working 60 hrs and caused stress well if she had to quit because of stress why didnt she have her doctor put her out on stress leave then she could have drew ei sick benifits .my husband worked in montaque while we lived in charlottetown he had no license and no he didnt loose his lic just moved here froma city where he had no need for lic but you know what while i was sick for @least 2 months and was not able to drive him to work he would leave our home at 4 in the morning to be at work for 7 and he would leave work and be home around 9 that night because he walked it so where is the justice here just because he was a man an took the job in montaque he didnt quit when time were hard in our house hold due to sickness no he done what he had to and this is no different in my eyes so dont go crying to the media because you choose to quit your job and refuse other jobs in montaque because it wasnt up to your standards .this articial totally disgrasses me as a women . if she can stand in the cold all day and have free food past out to her and coffee because it is so sad to see her stand there maybe she should give ei her cell number she can afford to keep it going and also able to talk on it as her pictures are being taken for her minutes of fame .if you are so concerned about your son take the job you are offered at the local retailers in montaque .

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Cry me a river
    - January 29, 2013 at 22:20:13

    She quit her job...enough said....and why's it always "single mom" I know many single dads who have to work every bit as hard and nobody feels for them when they lose their job-if women want equality stop playing the single mom card.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    SG
    - January 29, 2013 at 19:44:44

    WORKERBEE: She left her job due to having to work a 60 hr. week while being treated for Stress. Would you be able to work a 60 hr. week being a single Mother with a child and under stress? The current EI Changes are not only going to affect Marlene they are going to affect a Large number of Islanders given our recent Gov. Lay Offs and Lack of Job Opportunities. On top of that Islanders will soon be facing another problem ie: HST that will have a detrimental affect on our present Unemployed, low and middle income Islanders and all Islanders who are heating their homes via Electricity. But I was really happy to hear that our Federal and Provincial Governments had $ Hundreds of Thousands for Renovations for Community Centers in Rural PEI. Nice to see Islanders' Priorities getting attention!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Ms. Giersdorf "needed a break"
    - January 29, 2013 at 17:47:57

    Ms. Giersdorf told the National Post that she has been on E.I. a few times when she needed a break. The story is from The Globe and Mail, Toronto,Jan. 22, by Margaret Wente. Why do we not get answers from Ms. Giersdorf on the island?

    Submit a comment

  • Bill Kays
    Bill Kays
    - January 29, 2013 at 17:37:32

    EI may or may not be justified in refusing her, I am, not sure. But I am sure that MacAulay is jumping on the bandwagon only for one reason and that is to demonize this poor woman in the media. Yes, he makes it sound like he is sticking up for her rights by being the big champion of justice. But it is all a farce. By his taking up the issue it again breathes life into this unfortunate story. You see those in power want this to be the only story or at least the main story that people remember. The more the this story stays in the news the more the average person will gently be swayed not to pay attention to this or other stories like it. And that is what government wants. It wants to keep the public annoyed at this woman and not at the government for making the changes. It's the old bait and switch routine, or similar to distractions used by magicians.

    Submit a comment

  • Bill Kays
    Bill Kays
    - January 29, 2013 at 17:35:34

    EI may or may not be justified in refusing her, I am, not sure. But I am sure that MacAulay is jumping on the bandwagon only for one reason and that is to demonize this poor woman in the media. Yes, he makes it sound like he is sticking up for her rights by being the big champion of justice. But it is all a farce. By his taking up the issue it again breathes life into this unfortunate story. You see those in power want this to be the only story or at least the main story that people remember. The more the this story stays in the news the more the average person will gently be swayed not to pay attention to this or other stories like it. And that is what government wants. It wants to keep the public annoyed at this woman and not at the government for making the changes. It's the old bait and switch routine, or similar to distractions used by magicians.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    SlyFox
    - January 29, 2013 at 16:49:20

    That's right Frankie don't let the facts get in your way. She stated she did not own a phone,just because one can use a phone doe not mean they own one. Frankie how do you know the reason she was denied her claim ?Unless you work for Service Canada or your spouting B.S.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Frankie
    - January 29, 2013 at 15:46:07

    "Giersdorf, who doesn’t have a phone and works on a seasonal basis" ... well I've seen many pictures of her talking on a cell phone so that can't be true and the job she QUIT was at a nursing home, trust me, those aren't seasonal jobs!! I'm no fan of Harper but people need to get their facts straight before screaming from the hill tops. Her claim isn't being dropped because of not willing to work in Charlottetown, her claim is being dropped because she is not willing to work...PERIOD!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Islandwoman
    - January 29, 2013 at 15:42:28

    If she doesn't want to take the shuttle, is there no one in Montague that would offer her a drive to ch'town?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    spud
    - January 29, 2013 at 15:12:40

    Go back to the job you quit . We can't all be like the fishernen!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Good Ole Lawerance
    - January 29, 2013 at 14:21:24

    Lawerance is always looking to score politcal points-get to work Marlene-we are all stressed and dont want to travel to work but we do.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Single Parent
    - January 29, 2013 at 14:20:58

    As a single parent, every time I read about "poor Marlene the single mom" I get outraged. As a single woman who raised her son without government assistance, I am tired of hearing her poor me whine. If you can make it to Montague every morning to protest then you should be able to walk into the EI office every day and say "Find me work." and if you were doing that, you would have your unemployment check. If you cannot afford to live on minimum wage (I was able to make ends meet) then you don't have your priorities straight. It isn't easy, but neither is the decision to have a child and raise them. This story clearly shows she is not making the effort to walk into that building and look for work, she is too busy standing outside expecting her entitlement and 15 minutes of fame. And why is she not working at the coffee shop which offered her employment? or has that story changed again too?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    PS Good for Lawrence MacAulay
    - January 29, 2013 at 13:29:48

    At last we hear from Lawrence MacAulay and he's a good politician, good for Islanders. How can we get rid of what's in charge now and get some real politicians in power? Fed up with the present -- (what) dictatorship?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Brian
    - January 29, 2013 at 13:29:22

    If the government workers had to live on the poverty wages that most seasonal workers try to exist on they would be out protesting also but they don't have to worry their jobs are pains well off the working class . But yet they dictate to the people that pay their wages that they should do more to find work . While their wages keep going up. I am glad to see someone actually stick up for her rights . If all the money the government wastes was put out to more good paying jobs people would not have to try and survive on EI. Govt has a chance to set things right but I doubt it will happen. I hope they prove me wrong . We elect our govt not just to help the rich get richer but to try and help everyone in the country to be able to live not just survive!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    OH YEAH BLAME HER
    - January 29, 2013 at 13:22:43

    Put all the blame on Marlene and make her wait until Valentines Day. Maybe that lady Chief, Theresa, would have some fish broth left over that Marlene could share, that's good enough for the "needy", don't you think, Diane F? For goodness sake, this is Canada, what is wrong with our so-called leaders? Vice over virtue for certain. Angry, very angry and truely sorry.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    WorkerBee
    - January 29, 2013 at 13:20:18

    Really, SHE QUIT HER JOB!

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Expert bloggers

Ride for Heart
Blogger
Heart and Stroke Foundation
Putting those unused gears into action
[Sponsored]

More bloggers here

The Guardian Twitter

Advertising