• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (40)
  •  

Seasonal residents big contributors to P.E.I. economy: study

Seasonal residents and their visitors contribute significantly to P.E.I.'s economy. Tourism P.E.I. photo.

Seasonal residents and their visitors contribute significantly to P.E.I.'s economy. Tourism P.E.I. photo.

Published on January 23, 2013
Published on January 23, 2013
Teresa Wright  RSS Feed
Topics :
Tourism Research Centre , Prince Edward Island

Seasonal residents who own a second home on Prince Edward Island, and those who come to visit them are big contributors to the Island economy, says Tourism Minister Robert Henderson.

According to a new report published by the Tourism Research Centre for Tourism P.E.I., seasonal residents and their visitors spend just over $80 million a year in the province.

“It goes to show how important seasonal residents are to the Island economy and tourism industry,” Henderson said in a news release issued this morning.

“They pay property taxes, they pay for upgrades to those properties and they entice visitors to the Island that spend money on things like food and entertainment.”

The report is a profile of visitors to P.E.I. who purchase a seasonal second home on the Island, including details about the types of homes they purchase, how long they stay, how much they spend while here and other details about their demographics and activities.

The report also showed that 94 per cent of second-home owners had friends or family visit them in Prince Edward Island. 

Another notable finding showed that only about 34 per cent of those who came to visit second-home owners would have considered coming to the Island had they not known someone here. 

“As seasonal residents and, effectively, long-term visitors, second-home owners represent a unique and important segment of the province’s population,” said Dr. Susan Graham, Faculty Director of the TRC.

“They also act as tremendous ambassadors for Prince Edward

Island, by playing host to family and friends that come to visit.”

The survey showed that approximately two-thirds of second-home owners are Canadian and one-third American. Only 1.5 per cent of those surveyed were from another country.

Just over half of survey respondents indicated they have family ties to the province, with about one-third being former residents.

But Prince Edward Island’s appeal as a location for second-home owners appears to extend beyond family connections. Many respondents cited the province’s safe, quiet and relaxed environment as a reason for locating here, while others noted that they wanted a home near water.  

Ten per cent indicated they decided to purchase a second home on the Island after visiting to the province as a tourist.

Second-home owners and their visitors participate in many activities while on the Island. Visiting a beach, lake or river is the most popular activity among both groups, followed by shopping for local crafts, antiques and souvenirs.

Several other activities were also very popular amongst these groups, including visiting a national or provincial park, hiking or walking, and going on a driving tour or sightseeing.

 

To see the full Tourism Research Centre report, visit http://bit.ly/SecondHomePEI.

Comments

  • Username
    Islander
    - January 25, 2013 at 22:56:51

    If you don't like it here or can't afford it....don't come here. You're all happy to boast about your 2nd home or cottage you come to....great place to be you all say...well if it's that dear to your heart.....then move here. Otherwise,put up and shut up and be glad you can afford to partake of a piece of paradise

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    From Away
    - January 24, 2013 at 09:04:48

    PEI is a gem, the highlight being the people. Although the double tax does not bother many of us visitors, our concern for receiving adequate medical care is indeed a consideration that limits the length of our visits. If it is inadequate for Islanders, think how difficult it is for we visitors who have no status on the island.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Dale Larkin
    - January 24, 2013 at 08:26:59

    I have read many comments about double tax, I have to wonder how many of these cottage owners are renting their cottage to friends,family and co-workers and the real cost in lost revenue to the accommodation sector and the provincial treasurer. Was that cost figured into the study?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    We're "from away" even though we're here
    - January 24, 2013 at 07:59:45

    To all those "people from away" that angst about being shunned, we feel your pain. This government is so distant from our voice that Islanders not "from away" and living here all year long feel like we're "from away" as well. What hurts more, being disconnected by distance, birth place and taxation policy or being disconnected by inauthentic input into the entire decision making process? Issues like this Plan B thing puts it into bold relief (Google: Plan B PEI for more information). This government only cares about serving its own political interests. If anyone can find evidence that's not the case, please share it.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    observer
    - January 24, 2013 at 01:24:09

    I think that if you can afford to pay the purchase price for a second home in a country where so many can't even afford one home you have very little to complain about. What does that double tax amount to in a year? If you have a modest property it's not a lot of money to pay to help maintain services that you do use when you are here. I am thinking of roads, police services, community centres, and other things of that type. PEI has a limited land mass and of that limited area even less is the kind of property that summer home buyers want. So it's a desired commodity and you know what that means; you pay the premium. If you are not happy with the double tax why not buy in Nova Scotia or New Brunswick? Why buy here and then complain about it? Imagine the complaining you would be doing if the whole place was sold up and all that lovely atmosphere you like was eliminated. Talk about your first world problems.!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    justanotherislander
    - January 23, 2013 at 21:52:14

    Not Double Taxation I beg to differ with those who insist on saying that they are paying double property tax. Everyone is taxed at the same rate, but for permanent PEI residents, 50% of their property tax is forgiven. It is not for non-residents. The land use regulations which limit the amount of acreage a non-resident may own, is because of our unique situation of being a very, very, small Island. There is only so much acreage on this entire Island. If there were no restrictions, soon there would be no land available for permanent residents, and we would revert to the 1800's, when we were nothing but 'tenants' in our own land. It is imperative for our citizens, and for our future generation of citizens, that we are still able to be masters of our own domain. Those very welcome summertime residents must surely understand this situation. In general they are much wealthier than us, and with no restrictions, we could not compete to buy or own our own land. And we do not have very much land to begin with on this Island. Back where your permanent residence is....whereever that may be, it surely has much more land available than we have. How would you honestly feel if scores of people, much wealthier than you, from another area and/or country, bought up ALL your land? I think you might have a very different perspective. We are a friendly, generous, welcoming people, and we certainly welcome our tourists and our summer residents, but please do no deny us the right to protect a portion of our homeland.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      R. Penny
      - January 24, 2013 at 10:31:11

      I think the argument is still the same, but given your comment the argument can be reworded to say that non-residents pay the full tax amount generated by the tax rate, while islanders do not pay the full amount of taxes generated by the tax rate, or in other words, their fair share of taxes. Those "scores of wealthy people" buying PEI land, as you state, are buying the land in most cases from islanders hoping to make good money from the sale of their land. The fact that some or many islanders cannot afford some of the pricier pieces of land theselves is a reality in all georgraphic areas and is not specific to PEI - there is always land that garners a higher price than other pieces of land and people buy what they can afford. I would also suggest that judging by the glut of "for sale" signs on PEI of both lower priced homes and higher priced homes, availability of property on PEi is not an issue. The real issue is ensuring you have a market willing to buy both lower end properties and higher end properties because the real estate market is a critical indicator of economic stability and growth. And specifically in relation to this article, we want to encourage, not discourage, seasonal residents to continue their contribution of millions of dollars to our economy.

  • Username
    Linda C
    - January 23, 2013 at 21:43:11

    SG, there are three provinces/territories with a lower minimum wage, three that are the same and five are 15 to 30 cents more per hour. Nunavut is the only place whose minimum wage is over 10.30

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Kathy DelGaudio
      - January 24, 2013 at 08:13:03

      My husband Dino and I have been seasonal residents for the past 10 years. PEI is heaven on earth for us. We love the natural beauty of PEI and the many wonderful cultural and athletic events planned during the summertime, but the best resource the Island has are the Islanders. Everyone who visits us remark it is the People of PEI who make their vacation memorable. We're counting the days until we can be back.

  • Username
    Zimmer
    - January 23, 2013 at 18:10:56

    I visit PEI for about 5 weeks every year but would never buy a second home there because of the double taxation. Canada is a democracy where all the people are to be treated equally. If I wanted a second home where there are different degrees of equal, then I would move to Cuba.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      What's of real concern . . .
      - January 24, 2013 at 14:38:10

      "There is nothing more unequal than the equal treatment of unequal people." Socio-economic demographics have it that few people living on PEI can afford a cottage outside of PEI and of those fortunate people, fewer still would quibble about double taxation. I get it. And while I understand the principle and symbolic resistance to the double taxation policy, I doubt if it significantly impedes the purchase of property by those outside the province / country. When you're not a resident of any place there's all sorts of hoops to jump thought to buy property, this is just one of them. Besides, there's plenty of ways to get around that particular taxation policy if you're really inclined. Let's face it, how many "privileged" people pay their fair share of taxes anyway? It's not a real concern. I'm much more concerned about thoughtless infrastructure like the acidulous Plan B and conspicuous cell towers. Why live here in the summer if the government is going to make PEI look like the bloody place I'm escaping from? If summer residents are reading this, you really should Google Plan B PEI and find out what they're doing to our beautiful getaway!

  • Username
    Barry
    - January 23, 2013 at 16:28:26

    The picture is of two year round residents, they have lived full-time, all year around on PEI. Guardian, do your homework, picture does not fit the story!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    former islander
    - January 23, 2013 at 16:00:22

    So we contgribute significantly to the economy; entice others to come and visit the island and support the economy as well, and the Island government makes us feel welcome by limiting the land we can purchase and doubling the taxes we pay on that land, compared to the "residents" rate. Way to show your appreciation PEI!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Concerned
    - January 23, 2013 at 15:41:17

    Our family has had a home on PEI for 40+ years. At the risk of being accused of NIMBYism, I suggest that the gov't needs to be careful to support the working and natural lands as well as the shoreline, before they are eaten up by development and become part of the cookie-cutter honky-tonk seen along North America's coasts. It's not an either/or situation, however. Randall Arendt gave a wonderful presentation on the Island a few years ago about how this can be accomplished. Let's make sure that PEI's economy remains diverse, vibrant, and not over-dependent on any one sector.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    oh well
    - January 23, 2013 at 15:26:39

    Good job the seasonal residents like the peace & quiet here - soon all those of employable age will have left the Island, so it'll be one big retirement home. And charging non-residents extra for property taxes is criminal, it doesn't happen in other provinces. PEI is just a rip off.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    South Shore
    - January 23, 2013 at 14:41:11

    Imagine the economic spinoffs and benefits if we were able to entice these people and others to become full time residents and dont tell me about health care costs because they will be outweighed by their overall contribution to the economy. It should be easier to attract other canadians nearing retirement . Worked for Victoria other parts of BC and regions of Ontario outside of Toronto. A strategy to attract relatively wealth retiring Canadians to PEI should be closely evaluated.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      SAP
      - January 23, 2013 at 17:37:02

      That's the thing, it is a nice place to visit, living here year round, not so much for many people. There is a reason they are living elsewhere most of the time.

  • Username
    Kathy
    - January 23, 2013 at 14:37:02

    It is a very interesting article and it does not mention that if you live outside of PEI and have a seasonal or any kind or residence that you have to pay double taxes - for really no services - does not seem fair. Maybe the Province could look into this and abolish the double tax law. It is sad for people from PEI who have had to move away to find work to want to come home and own a piece of land, but no they are double taxed.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Islander
    - January 23, 2013 at 14:34:15

    Seasonal residents are not victimized by paying a higher tax rate. If they can afford a second home in the first place it shouldn't be a problem. We should all be so lucky! Secondly, amount of money spent is not the whole story. Seasonal residents are fine to a point, but PEI needs a year-round economy, not just part-time vacationers, to maintain a culture and a community that is well-developed enough to engage people full-time and at all ages.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      ARE YOU SERIOUS?
      - January 23, 2013 at 20:49:54

      Wish I could quote Forrest Gump without raising the ire of the moderators. Think before you write!

  • Username
    islander
    - January 23, 2013 at 14:14:46

    Just wondering do they have to pay taxes in ther home state or province the six months of the year they are not there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Molly
      - January 23, 2013 at 23:30:25

      Islander, yes we do have to pay taxes in our home state and province but it's NOT DOUBLE TAXES. The Island needs to treat us NOT as a cash cow.

  • Username
    Garth Staples
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:50:05

    The results of the study have been known for many years by private agencies on the Island which have 'targeted' this segment for business planning reasons. It was once known in the Dept of Tourism. Too bad the Govt spent so many taxpayers dollars to confirm what was already known; that unfortunately is the result of Govt Ministers and bureaucrat who are out of touch with the real world.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Carl B. MacLeod
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:31:14

    I was born on P.E.I., however left at 19 to pursue a career. My wife and I have owned a seasonal cottage for 25 years and of course have paid double taxes. A little known fact I'm sure, however P.E.I. is only one of three or four places in the free world to double tax non residents. We joined a class action suit many years ago against the Liberal government of the day in an attempt to repeal this grossly unfair money grab. Being a former Islander, I knew that this would not get past the appeal court of P.E.I., and it did not! Our lawyer was confident that if our law suit could be heard by the supreme court of Canada, it would have been a slam dunk for the plaintiffs. Simply put, the government appoint judges, so one would be foolhardy to bite the proverbial hand that feeds you. This article applauds seasonal home owners who only want to be treated like every other tax payer on P.E.I.!!!

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Planb'd like the rest of us . . .
      - January 24, 2013 at 08:44:56

      Believe me Carl, I'm sorry to say that, in every way but the quantity of your payments, you are being treated like every Islander.

  • Username
    james macgoo lakeside
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:24:35

    I have the opportunity to meet numerous "seasonal" resident/visitors. In the past 5 years there have been more comments concerning how they feel an increase in the way they are being taken advantage of by some island retailers/professions and government. They recognize they receive litte in return for taxes (real estate and when they purchase goods). They comment that in recent years they feel they are viewed as a cash machine that is expected to keep giving and enjoy receiving little. This is not a good value impression for the island to create. I also hear that many of their children do not come when they get older because of the costs associated with getting here and vacationing. Many people who visit and rent comment they had a great time, but due to costs when here, will not be back. They state they can receive better values other places. In the past years it is obvious where I am there are less people visiting or staying as long as they used to stay. Does the government view tourism as a major business activity? If yes, they need better focussed objectives, programs with businesses, and qualified people running the programs.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    'From Away'
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:22:57

    An encouraging economic boost to the Island economy indeed. But alas, wait until Islanders start seeing a proliferation of signs that read, "Private Road', 'Private Property' and 'Private Beach'. The rich may give, but they also like to take. Pay heed. I notice more private property signs each time I visit. Again, pay heed.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      ARE YOU SERIOUS?
      - January 23, 2013 at 20:56:21

      The Government designates a road as private or not; and, modern day waterfront properties stretch to the "Median High Water Mark" as confirmed in the survey...if it's dry, you are on private property. Think before you write!

  • Username
    Marie
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:10:29

    Yeh...like Mike Duffy... the double dipper...two principal residences in two provinces????CRA???? Pay them off through tax write offs (also illegal) and tell Canadians how much money you pump into PEI. Got to go...gagging...where do these statistics people come up with this crap???

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jim Crosbie
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:09:35

    My wife and I are seasonal residents that come "Home from Away" every eight weeks or so. My Mom was born in Millcove and I have been coming to the Island for about 64 years. I couldn't think of a place I'd rather be, higher property taxes and all.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    waste of money
    - January 23, 2013 at 13:08:04

    That TRC tax fraud should be shut down. What a waste of money on yet another useless report. People who own cottages on PEI like this place. Wow. Absolutely stunning Einstein.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    SG
    - January 23, 2013 at 12:54:31

    (....seasonal residents and their visitors spend just over $80 million a year in the province.) If Seasonal Residents and their visitors are spending $80 million per year in our Province why has our Province negotiated a $125 million Bond over a Forty Year Term? Why are Islanders experiencing Lay Offs and Lack of Job Opportunities and moving West to find employment? Why does our Province need to bring in HST to increase Tax Revenues? Why is our minimum wage at $10. per hour still the lowest in Canada while our Electricity Rate is the Highest and will be subject to two moer increases this year? Our household is finding it very difficult to survive financially. I'm Confused.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Art Cameron
    - January 23, 2013 at 12:53:30

    Most do not have children in school on the Island so are subsidizing PEI Education through taxes. Many do not receive any snow plowing in the winter. Many of the Island attitudes towards nonresidents needs correcting including the politicians. We are not cash cows to be milked for their bennifit. If you are an Islander, you pay Island prices versus prices charged to those "from away".

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    R. Penny
    - January 23, 2013 at 12:26:32

    This is a very interesting report. It should have been noted in the report/article that the seasonal residents pay more in property taxes than residents pay, and while contributing to the economy to the tune of $80 million per year, they do not require employment on the island; they just spend money. So taking the large contribution seasonal residents make to the economy into account, it would be prudent for the Commissioner reviewing the Lands Protection Act to ensure through this act that we encourage, and not discourage, the purchase of property for seasonal residential use by not making the process to purchase either costly or onerous.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Karen
    - January 23, 2013 at 11:54:18

    This article could not be more accurate. However, it should go on to show that most of those cottages are on private roads, maintained by the cottage owners and in most cases, paying double property taxes. Those property taxes provide nothing back to those taxpayers.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Tricia
      - January 23, 2013 at 14:27:40

      Thanks for noting that Karen. It's an important truth. It's a shame Canadians, and former Islanders in particular are charged so much for wanting a little place back home. If you are not a tax paying Canadian perhaps that rule should apply.

  • Username
    Confused??
    - January 23, 2013 at 11:45:38

    $80 million a year WOW!! I wonder how many more would consider buying PEI properties if the Government wasn’t punishing them with double property taxes. Seasonal residents reap very little benefits from property taxes and should not be victimized further with a higher tax rate.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Betty Pickens
      - January 23, 2013 at 14:07:54

      I agree with Confused ...why not lower the non resident's property taxes and see how many of the dirilect rural properties on the Island are sold in one year....see how they are fixed up...improved (think of the $ spent at local businesses for these improvements and upgrades..and see what a benefit it is to our economy. Try this for 3 years as a "pilot project" assess it and decide if it economically viable... and then decide to continue or not ...In today's economy anything that increases income and jobs should be tried to evaluate value . I believe as one who came as a vacationer and later returned to live here, that this would be a wonderful boost to Island economy. Lower the property taxes on vacation properties and absentee owners and see our financial gains!!

    • Username
      Part-time Islanders
      - January 23, 2013 at 17:41:17

      Nice to have it acknowledged that we "2nd home owners" from away contribute so much to the economy of this province. Besides encouraging others to visit the island and spend their dollars, as noted in the report, we consistently support the communities by attending local productions, make purchases at art galleries, take art classes, bid at auctions with the outcome of higher prices for the sellers, etc. All these things put money directly in the pockets of islanders. And this is in addition to the usual spending on groceries, liquor, gas, cottage repairs, etc that are all generate taxes for the province. And we pay MORE property taxes that islanders do. Yes, in return we get to enjoy a nice life-style but don't use any government services except for the highways. We can't get a regular doctor and if we do see one in Emergency, the costs are charged to our home province. We maintain the road to our cottage. We don't use the school system. So, we agree that the province should rethink the additional property taxes charged to out-of-province second home-owners as we contribute to the economy in many other ways and cost the province little if anything.

    • Username
      John Malone
      - January 23, 2013 at 18:02:55

      I was born on PEI have a lot of family on PEI I like to tell people I am an Islander. It is to bad the PEI goverment is only interested in what we can spend and who we can bring home to show of the Island to. When your Gov. treats you like you are from away no wonder people who are from away are treated that way by the people who live on the Island 12 months a year and make sure you know it. They are just following the Gov. lead Spend your money and get of OUR Island. What ever you do dont cause us to give you any thing back. I dont mind putting my name on this. John Malone

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Expert bloggers

Ride for Heart
Blogger
Heart and Stroke Foundation
Putting those unused gears into action
[Sponsored]

More bloggers here

The Guardian Twitter

Advertising