• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (17)

P.E.I. politicians air "fracking" concerns

Opposition Leader Olive Crane and PC MLA Jim Bagnall enter the P.E.I. legislature on Thursday. Guardian photo by Heather Taweel

Opposition Leader Olive Crane and PC MLA Jim Bagnall enter the P.E.I. legislature on Thursday.

Published on April 15, 2011
Published on April 15, 2011
Jim Day  RSS Feed
Topics :
Corridor Resources , Prince Edward Island , Canada , Green Gables

The increasingly controversial drilling practice of hydraulic fracturing will not get a green light on Prince Edward Island without first undergoing a thorough environmental assessment and public consultation, says the province’s environment minister.

Richard Brown says his department will be extremely cautious if and when it issues any permit to allow companies to drill in P.E.I. by so-called fracking, which involves injecting large quantities of water along with secret mixes of chemicals deep underground in order to break up gas-containing rock formations.

“If there’s problems with fracking, if it has any potential to hurt our groundwater or to hurt the environment or hurt the fisheries in any ways, we’re not going to allow it to happen,’’ Brown told a group of reporters outside the legislature Thursday.

Opposition house leader Jim Bagnall urged Brown to have his department conduct environmental assessments now on the potential impact fracking may have in the province. Bagnall says he fears the process could contaminate groundwater on P.E.I., which he notes is “the only province in Canada that relies 100 per cent on ground water.’’

While the gas industry argues that the chemical-infused technique is perfectly safe and vital to reaching vast gas supplies, concerns about its potential impact on water supplies is growing.

“Look I’m extremely concerned about fracking and the potential problems it may have to our ground water,’’ said Brown.

“The honourable house leader was correct: there is a tremendous amount of concern out there. I’m concerned about it also and that’s why when the permit was issued to PetroWorth it was made clear to them no drilling will occur – no drilling will occur – unless there’s a full environmental assessment done.’’

Brown says PetroWorth has a permit for a substantial amount of land, basically the entire eastern end of the Island, which gives them the right to the resources that can be discovered on that property.

“It doesn’t give them the right to drill,’’ he stressed. “They’re basically not allowed to do any drilling or any activity on those properties unless they come back to the department for approval before they do anything.’’

Brown says PetroWorth has not requested a permit to conduct any fracking under its current permit, which expires December 2012. Fracking by a drilling company in 2007 resulted in a spill involving low levels of radioactive material near Green Gables.  Corridor Resources was looking for natural gas in Cavendish.

To release the gas, a high- pressure mixture of water and sand was forced into the ground to crack the rock but the pipe holding the fluid broke. P.E.I.’s environment department had the company ship the waste off the Island.

Brown says an environmental assessment and public consultation took place before that fracking was given the go ahead. Brown is keeping a keen eye on the work environment departments in neighbouring provinces are doing in studying the potential impact of fracking.

“We will take the information from those analysis and those studies and their comments into our consideration here on Prince Edward Island and before a drilling permit would be issued all those studies would have to be tabled,’’ he said. “They would have to be looked at.’’

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

  • Username
    Andrew Lush
    - April 23, 2011 at 12:09:53

    So we want jobs and gas, but at the expense of our well-water? I don't think so. I thought this was a stupid idea before I investigated the process, now I just feel sorry for all the sick and dying people in the USA who have been poisoned by fracking, and have to have all their water brought in by tanker. And they have been bribed by the gas companies to keep quiet about it...

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    dale payson
    - April 18, 2011 at 13:30:34

    Check out Petroworth's website. They are invading all of the maritimes. Greed is the only motive. Why would the government issue a permit if it didn't expect drilling. Don't let the politicians sacrifice the island. Look at the companies that said Ocean drilling off New Orleans was safe, that said Nuclear power stations in Japan were safe. If you give over to the Oil and Gas explorers we have given away the farm, literally.

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Jason Arsenault
      - April 20, 2011 at 19:02:51

      It is truly an uneducated comment by saying this I am originally from Charlottetown and live in Alberta now and working in the oilfield and am very familiar with fracturing there is no water issues here in alberta as a result of fracturing and what it does for the economy out here in spin offs, employment and buisness is make it prosper and as it sits PEI can use all the help it can get, yes accidents do happen but people only here about the negatives but believe me there is much more positive. So please keep an open mind and consider the benifits of what it can do for PEI.

  • Username
    Mell
    - April 17, 2011 at 15:13:55

    Greed is the only reason for fracking by the oil and gas companies. Greed would be the only reason to ruin the lands, the waters, the infrastructure, the pastures and peace that PEI has to offer. It will change your lives for the worse. It is worth checking out the program from CBC, or go on line. to see Lands and Sea episode of fracking and the evil it has produced for people in Pennyslvania and perhaps future evil closer to PEI in New Brunswick. DO NOT LET THIS HAPPEN.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Biffy McClyde
    - April 16, 2011 at 00:27:35

    The answer here may be much easier. Do you know how many millionairre high school drops outs live in Alberta? Thousands! Yes, drop outs. I know more over paid drop outs in Alberta due to the rich oil and gas economy AB has to offer. Meanwhile every tom bill and mary has a degree on PEI, you think they are getting an equal chance at employment? Nope. some are still working at the same pubs when they were getting those degrees for crying out loud. Frac the stupid well, create a new stream of wealth on PEI, Albertans have proven that it doesn't take a lot of brainpower. P5422ises me off that I know drop outs here in AB making 100K plus, with a downtown office overlooking the city, big homes, fancy cars. Frac the stupid well, its proven technology!

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Cory Jackson
      - September 29, 2011 at 09:34:46

      People on the island aren't wrapped up in becoming millionaires. We want to live where we are safe and have the adequate things for survival. Drinking water and our watersheds are part of those things. We can do without the cash, we'd rather be living poor then dieing rich!

  • Username
    richlind
    - April 16, 2011 at 00:25:47

    PLEASE NO! i have been coming to PEI for 5 years now on vacation and can honestly say i LOVE it! We do alot of traveling and there is no other place i have been that i find so beautiful. the gaswell industry has been in our community now for 4 years and it sucks! so many people have had trouble with there water, and one friend of ours has to move because they can't fix his water. he can light his water on fire! yes, i know the gas companies bring in money to our community, but no amount of money is worth this! we own our home, but people who have lived here for many years, can't afford to rent , because the cost of renting has skyrocketed, because people know they can gouge the gas people. if i knew this was going to happen when we bought our house 17 years ago, i would of never bought it. the gas companies are ruining our roads as well. i beg you, please, don't let PEI be ruined by fracking and gas companies. we have even considered buying a home on PEI. i sure wouldn't want to if i have to deal with the gas companies again. KEEP PEI BEAUTIFUL!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Thom Oommen
    - April 15, 2011 at 14:39:47

    Just wanted to explain the use of 'secret' in this article. Private oil and gas companies develop their own cocktail of fracking chemicals which is proprietary. This means that they don't share their mix with the public since that would put them at a competitive disadvantage. Governments may know but can't disclose for the same contractual reason. This is really helpful if a well is contaminated because you can't ask them to disclose their chemicals. Unless you can afford a high priced lawyer perhaps. Remember everyone for government and industry profits come first. More and more citizens are standing up against fracking. Everywhere in the Maritimes people are calling for bans on this risky technology. As someone who lives on a well t's just not worth the risk. Ban fracking and get moving on renewables and conservation!

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    R Magnusson
    - April 15, 2011 at 14:38:34

    As someone who formerly worked in the oil and gas industry, I can tell you that -- given a preference -- I would rather not have this process used near my community, or my well.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    pat
    - April 15, 2011 at 14:37:57

    Ever drink the water in Alberta? That will tell you what fracing will do to the drinking water. Lots of house holds have to have their water trucked in to their homes and have a big storage tank to hold it cuz the water isn't safe to drink.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    fracking is as safe as blowing up beaver dams
    - April 15, 2011 at 12:48:32

    Dynamite Richard spewing forth his knowledge, as usual. Why can't we actually have an environment minister with REAL credentials instead of the lip service premier after premier has given this position?

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Astalavista
      - April 16, 2011 at 23:27:40

      Risks of fracking involve: contamination of groundwater aquifers with fracturing chemicals or waste fluids, the migration of gasses and fracturing chemicals, the mishandling of waste, increased risk of cancers and other illnesses from contaminated aquifers and air pollution near drilling sites, and decreased air quality. It is clear that we don't have regulations or technological advances to resolve any cost of environmental clean up processes, lost of land value near fracking sites, as well as "undetermined" human and animal health concerns.

  • Username
    Linda Fossett
    - April 15, 2011 at 12:34:44

    If you think is safe just watch the movie Gasland by Josh Fox.

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      Concerned Islander
      - April 16, 2011 at 18:20:20

      I was about to say the exact same thing. This documentary is extremely eye opening. Definately a MUST SEE for all of those who actually think that "Fracing" is a good idea in PEI! Unless of course you enjoy being able to light your water on fire from your tap!!!

  • Username
    Amand Arsenault
    - April 15, 2011 at 12:33:31

    Fracking should not be allowed...PERIOD...on PEI or in any other province. The fact that past "fracking" activities resulted in radioactive materials being leaked, god only knows what other chemicals could potentially be leaked into our grounwater, which we depend on here on PEI. A geologist yesterday on Maritime Noon admitted that there is no way of knowing where these injection of chemicals could end up when underground, let alone the devastation to the lanscape that is usuallly involved in this type of operation. Being that PEI is mostly shale/sand based, the more risk there is for seepage into our groundwater. I would strongly encourage all of our provincial representatives to ban fracking altogether on PEI. The risks are too great. Sincerely...Amand Arsenault

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    We can't trust the Minister
    - April 15, 2011 at 09:07:11

    This is the same minister we couldn't trust to clean up that garbage site last fall......time for Ghiz to Shuffle Brown

    Submit a Comment

    • Username
      John Banks
      - April 15, 2011 at 09:43:23

      Why do they describe the chemicals as 'secret' --that sounds sinister. Why not just report the facts?

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Guardian is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Expert bloggers

Ride for Heart
Blogger
Heart and Stroke Foundation
Preparation is key
[Sponsored]

More bloggers here

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

The Guardian Twitter

Advertising