GE salmon eggs raise concern with P.E.I. groups



Published on November 22nd, 2010
Published on November 22nd, 2010
 
Topics :
GE , Environment Canada , Island coalition , P.E.I. , Bay Fortune , U.S.

An Island coalition is demanding that Environment Canada disclose if it has begun an environmental assessment of production of genetically engineered (GE) Atlantic salmon eggs at a facility in Bay Fortune, P.E.I.

The company, AquaBounty, has asked the United States Food and Drug Administration to approve its GE Atlantic salmon for human consumption in the U.S. A final decision could be made as early as Tuesday.

The coalition is calling on Premier Robert Ghiz to intervene and get answers.

AquaBounty plans to produce all of its GE salmon eggs at Bay Fortune. It will then ship the eggs to Panama for growing out and processing and then sell into the U.S.

 There is a global controversy about the health and environmental impact of GE salmon as well as the inadequacy of the scientific evidence presented by AquaBounty to the FDA, says Leo Broderick of the Council of Canadians.

"Both AquaBounty and Environment Canada refuse to tell the public if an environmental assessment for GE fish eggs has even begun," said Broderick.

He said he called Environment Canada who refused to answer if they are currently looking at an application from AquaBounty, saying this information was confidential.

"Environment Canada must immediately tell P.E.I. residents if they have already begun their 120 day process to approve GE salmon eggs production here.

"It's outrageous that the public has no input at all and cannot know when or if the process has started. Premier Ghiz must intervene in the interest of protecting P.E.I.'s environment and reputation," adds Broderick.

"And why is there no public input? And why is the province excluded in the process," said Sharon Labchuk of Earth Action P.E.I.

She said Environment Canada will assess the environmental risks of commercial scale GE salmon egg production in a completely secret process. The

department must reach its decision in 120 days of receiving a request.

 "We hope the premier will play a positive and proactive role in providing transparency for Islanders," said Mary Boyd of the P.E.I. Health Coalition.

The group is asking the premier to insist Environment Canada notify the province when it begins an environmental assessment for GE salmon egg production, that the province be consulted on environmental risk questions and be notified immediately if approval is granted.

It also wants to hold public consultations on whether or not AquaBounty should be permitted to produce GE salmon eggs on P.E.I.

The group is also calling on the Canadian government to ban the sale of any GE animal, and to introduce legislation declaring P.E.I. a GMO-free province.

 

Comments

  • Username
    Matt
    - November 24th, 2010 at 09:10:17

    Greg, I understand your points and agree with you BUT this wasn't just created over the last 6 months and is rushing through the approval process like everyone seems to think it is. I have been following this (and Enviropig) with great interest since I heard that the FDA is considering approving it (them) and have read in a few articles where Aqua Bounty states that they have been studying and submitting requested data to the FDA for over ten years (here is one off the top of my head - http://www.theguardian.pe.ca/Opinion/Letters-to-editor/2010-10-06/article-1825392/Biotechnology-is-no-game/1). You also have to realize that there is more than a single organization involved in the regulations, I can think of at least three (DFO, Environment Canada, and FDA) and I am sure that there are more. I’m sure they are not going to let something that could potentially be disastrous go through without serious scrutiny. As for companies looking to achieve a good bottom line, you would be foolish if you don’t agree that ALL companies do this. If it wasn't for the bottom line you wouldn't have had your Wheaties for breakfast this morning or a table to eat them on and you surely would not have driven your car to work... I am sure you also appreciate a good personal bottom line, after all who wants to work for nothing? My original point was that I would like to see Leo and Sharon (who oppose EVERYTHING) just shut up for a change. I don't mind a good oppositional argument but it gets redundant when it’s the same people causing it over and over again, and most of the time they don’t have even half of the facts straight. For them it’s not about the company, the product or the environment, it’s about being in the spotlight…

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Greg
    - November 23rd, 2010 at 23:54:57

    @ Matt : Clearly you need to educate yourself more on GE organisms. There's a world of questions that haven't been answered yet and quite frankly wont be able to be answered until years of research have been completed. You need to understand what we create is not in harmony with "original nature" and could have unexpected if not disastrous results 15 years down the road. Remember end of the day the corporate entity is only looking to achieve one thing and one thing only. Its bottom line. Anything else is inconsequential. Look beyond the dollar signs and economic growth.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Matt
    - November 23rd, 2010 at 13:58:55

    Are there any other islanders that are tired of listening to Sharon and Leo's constant complaints? If it were up to them we would all still live in dark caves (FIRE BAD!!!). Do they ever see any of the good in anything? What about all the jobs and revenue this company is generating for our province? Technology is the future and I think it's fantastic that a world first is happening right here on our own little island! This is what all the hard work, and money spent trying to attract biotech based companies here to the island is all about. We should be standing behind them, not complaining about them when they do something worthwhile....

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Guardian is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Expert bloggers

Ride for Heart
Blogger
Heart and Stroke Foundation
Preparation is key
[Sponsored]

More bloggers here

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

The Guardian Twitter

Advertising